Talk Back
Login to view our forums
Tools
Send us a note!
Login
Sign Up!
Send an E-Card!
Print This
Customize Site
Our Newsletter

View Newsletter Archive
Poll
No active polls.
View poll results
Prvtgov.org

An Article
AARP submits amicus brief in Twin Rivers constitutionality suit

They support freedom of speech

November 03, 2006

By George K. Staropoli (View author info)

Trenton, New Jersey -

This AARP brief in the Twin Rivers constitutionality case is a must read, and should be brought to the attention of your legislators. A few excerpts:

"The Hannaman Report [NJ agency report, 10 years ago is notable for its candor and its breadth.

For example, Mr. Hannaman states:

"It is obvious from the complaints [to DCA (Dept of Consumer Affairs)] that that [home]owners did not realize the extent association rules could govern their lives." Pa237. Mr.Hannaman goes on to set forth at length numerous examples of abuse of homeowner rights by New Jersey ineffectual and inadequate safeguards prevent and remedy such abuse." P.4.

"Perhaps most alarming is the revelation that boards, or board presidents desirous of acting contrary to law, their governing documents or to fundamental democratic principles, are unstoppable without extreme owner effort and often costly litigation." P. 5.

"It is no answer to say (as Appellants do) that private contractual agreements, or the "business judgment rule," somehow trump constitutional principles, and that New Jersey community association residents have no constitutional rights because of some sort of "waiver" arising from the documents they signed when purchasing their homes." P. 20.

The proposition that residents of Twin Rivers have no less a right to speak than nonresidents flows inexorably from these core principles. And the same result obtains by application of the "unconstitutional conditions" doctrine, and by application of the principle that servitudes that are either contrary to public policy or unconstitutional are unenforceable. P. 24.


The entire amicus curiae brief can be found in the attached file.

Note: The New Jersey Supreme Court has yet to accept the amicus application. The HOA strongly opposes the filing of the brief, yet it had no objection to a brief by Community Associations Institute, CAI, that has a strong, non-neutral, stance with respect to the outcome of the Court's decision.
 
View Comments (0) | Post a comment
 
For more information, please check out the articles listed below:
  • Community Associations Institute - CAI - Central Arizona District
  • Skip Daum - CLAC - California Legislative Action Committee - CAI
  • Beth A. Grimm - CAI Foreclosure Lobbyist- Publicist - Condo Guru
  • Steven Shuey - - CAI Manager & Activist - Desert Sun Columnist
  • Margaret G. Wangler - CAI lawyer - Desert Sun Columnist
  • Sam Dolnick - CAI lobbyist , director
  • Responsible Neighbors.com - A CAI Website to lobby for HOA Foreclosure laws
  • Tom Skiba - Frank Rathburn -Christoper Durso - Propagandists for CAI foreclosure lawyers
  • Chris Durso - Common Ground - Community Association Institute's (CAI)
  • AARP - Sacramento Lobbyists
  • Lupe De La Cruz - Lobbyist for AARP - California
  • AARP
  • BUYING AWAY YOUR CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS - A. R. Ross
  • STATEMENT OF RUTGERS LAW SCHOOL PROFESSOR FRANK ASKIN ON DECISION IN TWIN RIVERS CASE - Professor Frank Askin
  • HOA constitutionality questioned in New Jersey appeals case - George K. Staropoli
  • New Jersey Court Says Homeowner Associations Must Respect Residents' Free Speech Rights - American Civil Liberties Union
  • Constitutional Litigation Clinic Wins Landmark Decision Guaranteeing Free Speech Rights to Residents of Homeowner Associations - Constitutional Clinic -Rutgers State University
  • Case Number: DOCKET NO. C-121-2000 - Committee for a Better Twin Rivers RIVERS v Twin R
  • Case Number: A-4047-03T24047-03T2 - Appellate Opinion: Twin Rivers vs Twin Rivers Home
  • Rutgers State University of New Jersey - Center for Law and Justice
  • Submitted Files
    Filename Description File Type File Size Click to download
    AARPamicus.pdf AARP Amicus Curiae brief to NJ Supreme Court PDF document, version 1.3 120KB Download

    American Homeowners Resource Center (AHRC)
    PO Box 97 • San Juan Capistrano • California • 92693
    Email:

    © 1990-2010 • AHRC News Services

    Disclaimer: AHRC is an interactive information WEBSITE. The information contained here is that of the users. It is not the opinion of AHRC. AHRC does not WARRANT the accuracy, reliability or timeliness of any information and shall not be liable for any losses caused by such reliance on the accuracy, reliability, or timeliness of such information. See guidelines for publishing

    Powered by AHRCwebsites